What will happen?
Live values
Switch the view (frame of reference) and watch how the same motion looks different. The real physics does not change.
Theory
Relative velocity is the velocity of one object as seen by another. The velocity of A as seen from B is:
Both velocities are measured from the same reference (usually the ground). Velocities are vectors, so subtract the x parts and y parts separately.
River and boat: The boat moves in the water, and the water moves with the river. The velocity of the boat as seen from the ground is the vector sum:
Heading angle α (measured from straight across, towards upstream):
across speed = vb cosα, along-river speed = vr − vb sinα
Time to cross: T = w / (vb cosα) Drift: d = (vr − vb sinα) T
- Shortest time: point the boat straight across (α = 0). Then T = w / vb and drift = vr T.
- Shortest path (zero drift): point the boat upstream so that sinα = vr / vb. This is possible only if vb > vr. Then T = w / √(vb² − vr²).
- The river speed does not change the time to cross. Only the across-speed matters.
Rain and man: The rain falls at velocity vrain. A walking man sees the rain coming with:
For vertical rain and a man walking at vm: tanθ = vm / vrain
- The best umbrella tilt is along the direction opposite to the relative rain velocity, so the rain hits the umbrella head-on.
- The faster you walk, the more you must tilt the umbrella forward.
- If the wind blows the rain at the same horizontal speed as you walk, the rain falls straight down for you.
Two moving objects: From the frame of A, object B moves in a straight line with the relative velocity vBA = vB − vA. If the starting position of B (as seen from A) is r0:
Time of closest approach: t* = −(r0 · vBA) / |vBA|²
Closest distance: dmin = |r0 + vBA t*|
- They collide only if the relative velocity points straight at the other object, so that dmin = 0.
- If t* is negative, the objects are already moving apart.
- Head-on: speeds add. Same direction: speeds subtract.
Practice questions
Q1. A river 100 m wide flows at 3 m/s. A boat moves at 5 m/s in still water and points straight across. Find the time to cross, the drift and the speed seen from the bank.
T = 100 / 5 = 20 s
Drift = 3 × 20 = 60 m
Speed = √(5² + 3²) = 5.83 m/s
Q2. For the same boat and river, at what angle should it point to reach the point exactly opposite? How long will it take?
sinα = 3 / 5, so α = 36.9° upstream.
Across speed = √(25 − 9) = 4 m/s, so T = 100 / 4 = 25 s.
Q3. Can a boat of speed 3 m/s reach the point exactly opposite in a river flowing at 5 m/s?
No. It needs sinα = 5 / 3, which is more than 1. The boat must be faster than the river.
Q4. Rain falls vertically at 10 m/s. A man walks at 5 m/s. At what angle should he hold the umbrella? What is the speed of the rain as he sees it?
tanθ = 5 / 10, so θ = 26.6° from the vertical, tilted forward.
Speed = √(10² + 5²) = 11.18 m/s
Q5. A man walks at 4 m/s and the vertical rain falls at 4 m/s. Find the umbrella angle.
tanθ = 4 / 4 = 1, so θ = 45°.
Q6. Car A moves east at 20 m/s and car B moves north at 15 m/s. Find the velocity of B as seen from A.
vBA = (0, 15) − (20, 0) = (−20, 15)
Magnitude = 25 m/s, direction = 36.9° north of west.
Q7. A ship A moves east at 10 m/s. Ship B is 500 m due north of A and moves south at 10 m/s. Find the closest distance between them.
vBA = (0, −10) − (10, 0) = (−10, −10), r0 = (0, 500)
t* = −(0 × (−10) + 500 × (−10)) / 200 = 25 s
r = (0, 500) + 25 × (−10, −10) = (−250, 250), so dmin = 353.6 m
Q8. Two trains are 500 m apart on the same track. A moves east at 15 m/s and B moves west at 10 m/s. When do they meet?
Relative speed = 15 + 10 = 25 m/s. Time = 500 / 25 = 20 s.
Tip: Put the values in the controls above and check your answers in the simulation.